Mammals and Birds Now Considered Conscious, as the Boundary Extends to Octopuses, Crabs, and Bees

The debate about machines highlights an older question: which living beings actually experience anything at all? Since 2012, two researchers’ statements and a British report have reshaped the map of consciousness. Their common thread remains caution, because the boundary shifts as evidence about animals accumulates.

The Cambridge Declaration, signed in July 2012, first recognized consciousness in mammals, birds, and octopuses

On July 7, 2012, during the Francis Crick Memorial Conference in Cambridge, a group of neuroscientists adopted a concise statement. According to this Cambridge Declaration, the absence of a neocortex does not prevent an organism from experiencing affective states. Thus, mammals, birds, and other species such as octopuses would possess the neural substrates of consciousness.

This text remains mainly neurobiological. Indeed, it compares brains and behaviors, with no moral implication. Furthermore, the mention of octopuses was partly explained by a presentation devoted to cephalopods during the conference, according to commentators of the text.

The November 2021 report by Jonathan Birch’s team brought crabs and octopuses into British law

Commissioned by the United Kingdom’s Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (Defra), a London School of Economics report reviewed more than 300 studies. Led by philosopher Jonathan Birch, it concluded with solid evidence of sentience in decapod crustaceans and cephalopod mollusks. However, the strength of the evidence varied, very strong for octopuses, more limited for squids, cuttlefish and lobsters.

This work had a tangible effect. Subsequently, the bill, initially limited to vertebrates, was amended in November 2021. The Animal Welfare (Sentience) Act 2022 received royal assent on April 28, 2022, and established a committee tasked with evaluating the impact of public policies on these animals.

Bees that roll balls without reward revived the question of emotions in insects in 2022

In October 2022, Lars Chittka’s team at Queen Mary University of London published in Animal Behaviour a study led by Hiruni Samadi Galpayage Dona. The researchers tracked 45 ground-nesting bumblebees in an arena. These insects diverted from their path to food to push small wooden balls.

Some individuals rolled a ball up to 117 times. Moreover, the bees then preferred the color of the chamber associated with the balls, even when the chambers were empty. The authors interpret this as a behavior reminiscent of play, voluntary and not yielding an immediate benefit. However, they frame it as an indicator of positive states, not as proof of consciousness.

Launched on April 19, 2024, in New York, a new declaration considers consciousness in fish and insects realistic

Presented at a conference at New York University, the New York Declaration was initiated by Jeff Sebo, Kristin Andrews, and Jonathan Birch. It lays out two levels. On the one hand, a strong scientific backing for conscious experience in mammals and birds. On the other, a realistic possibility among other vertebrates and many invertebrates, including cephalopods, decapods, and insects.

The text adds an ethical dimension. Consequently, disregarding this possibility in decisions affecting these animals would be irresponsible. Around forty researchers signed at the launch, with several hundred more joining later. Yet some specialists regard the evidence as still inconclusive.

The baseline of the debate remains. None of these declarations include viruses or amebas, which lack a nervous system. Thus, the current boundary no longer separates humans from the rest of life, but rather cuts through the world of invertebrates, where the evidence is still the thinnest.

Liam Kennedy avatar

Leave a comment

Contact details

Address:
Farmers Forum,
36, Dominick Street,
Mullingar,
Co. Westmeath,
Ireland

Phone:
+353 (0)44 9310206

Or email us:

For technical issues please check out our FAQ's page or email - [email protected]

For general Queries email - [email protected]

Request to add event to our Calendar - [email protected]

Send us your mart reports - [email protected]

Suggestions and feedbacks - [email protected]

News Items / Press Release - [email protected]

To Advertise on Farmers Forum - [email protected]